Whenever Eduflack writes about the “successes” of New York City’s school improvement efforts under Chancellor Joel Klein, I get publicly flogged by some audience or another. Most take significant issue with my conclusions that NYC Department of Education has improved the quality of the public schools. Others take issue with giving Klein (and NYC Mayor Michael Bloomberg) credit for such school improvement. And even if I can get the opposition to acknowledge an uptick in student achievement in NYC, they will immediately retort that the gains are minimal, and not nearly enough to declare turnaround efforts in New York a success.
My responses to such criticism have been relatively simple. The test scores, at least on New York’s state exams, do show gains in both reading and math in NYC. If you don’t believe the final tallies coming from Albany, you should at least acknowledge that NYC has won the Broad Prize, and that Broad similarly crunched the numbers and found academic gains across the city. And if the gains aren’t big enough for you yet, first, give it time. Then remember how large the NYCDOE truly is. Upticks in a system that size are worthy of praise.
Always a glutton for punishment, Eduflack is going to raise the NYC achievement flag again. Today, we’re going to reflect on a forum hosted yesterday by the Alliance for Excellent Education. Offering a multi-hour symposium yesterday under the banner of “Informing Federal Education Policy Through Lessons from New York City,” the Alliance also put a spotlight on a new report it has released, “New York City’s Strategy for Improving High Schools.”
So let’s take a look at the most recent set of numbers, namely four-year high school graduation rates. The Alliance took a look at four different calculations of NYC graduation data from 2002 to the present. By NYC’s own calculations, grad rates rose more than 29 percent from 2002 to 2008, from 51 percent to 66 percent. According to the state calculation, rates increased nearly 52 percent, from 40 percent to 61 percent. EdWeek has the number increasing 35 percent from 2002 to 2006 (37 percent to 50 percent). And Jennifer Jennings and Leonie Haimson have the grad rates lifted nearly 18 percent from 2002 to 2007 (40 percent to 47 percent).
Let’s set aside, for a second, the fact that no one started with the same 2002 baseline. (yes, we still have problems with data collection and such) Even if we throw out the top score and the bottom score (in the Olympic tradition), we are still looking at a gain in NYC’s high school graduation rates of nearly 33 percent from where we started in 2002. In an era of drop-out factories and rising dropout rates, such numbers in NYC are worth paying attention to.
Whether you like the rhetoric coming out of NYCDOE or not, you can’t deny that the Klein plan has had a real impact, and an impact for the good. As other urban centers struggle to deal with graduation rate challenges, NYC has found real solutions. And it has done so applying a four-year graduation rate formula (a calculation many fear because it offers a lower grad rate than many want to admit.)
Moreover, NYC has been able to apply its high school reforms to help close the achievement gap. According the Alliance, “since 2005, the black-white and Hispanic-white [graduation rate] gaps have narrowed by 16 percent and 14 percent respectively.”
New York City may still be a work in progress, but aren’t these the sorts of numbers we are working toward? Klein and company offer a clear plan for how they are going to fix the problems (a plan so clear that it draws a with us/against us line). They take the necessary steps to implement that plan, regardless of the “friends” it may create. And then they have the data to demonstrate effectiveness, with both test scores and graduation rates rising. Isn’t that our ultimate end game? And if it isn’t shouldn’t it be?
Buy xanax.
Buy xanax.
Cialis.
Cialis review. Cialis murah klang. Cialis no prescription. Cialis. Cialis versus levitra.
Soma.
Soma intimates. Effects of soma. Cheap soma. Soma to florida. Soma. Pornstar soma. Buy domain onlinevcvpl soma. Drug soma.
Ephedrine faq.
Ephedrine products for asthma.
Ephedra yellow swarm.
Wyoming ephedra lawyer. Ephedra yellow jackets. Ephedra solaray. Ephedra.
Can i drink alcohol if i m taking amoxicillin.
Amoxicillin lowest. Amoxicillin. Safety of amoxicillin and greyhounds. Amoxicillin trial strep pharyngitis.
Diet pills with ephedra.
Ephedra in local gas stations.
Double action ephedrine.
Ephedrine. Biotek ephedrine. Ephedrine chicken feed.
Amoxicillin.
Amoxicillin and clavulanate potassium. Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin safe when pregnant. Can amoxicillin be used for acne.
Amoxicillin no prior prescription.
Amoxicillin rx655. Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin dosage. Amoxicillin soar throat.
Buy amoxicillin.
Kennel cough amoxicillin. Side effects of amoxicillin. Buying amoxicillin and clavulanate. Non prescription amoxicillin for cats.
Buy amoxicillin without prescription.
Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin dosage. Amoxicillin and vagina.
Soma.
Soma groove. Soma. Soma drug.
Soma.
Buy soma. Soma. Soma without a prescription. Cheap soma. Order soma carisoprodol.
Amoxicillin alternative.
Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin acne.
Soma beds.
Soma addiction and lying. Buy cheap soma. Soma online sales. Soma.
Homemade ephedrine.
Ephedrine. Ephedrine products. Method of action of ephedrine. Ephedrine for pleasure. Chronic ephedrine abuse. Vaspro ephedrine. Hb p-ephedrine guaifen la ta information. Ephedrine..
Buy xanax.
Xanax.
Cialis.
Cialis.
Cialis.
Cialis in las vegas. Cialis st. How cialis works. Buying generic cialis. Cialis.
Generic xanax 2 mg no prescription.
Side effects of drug xanax. Xanax. Xanax without a prescription. Xanax effect.
Cialis.
Buy cialis online. Cod phentermine as well as cialis cheap reviews. Taking cialis. Cialis.
Ephedra.
Atlanta ephedra attorneys. Ephedra. Buy ephedra online. Where can i purchase ephedra.
Ephedra weight loss products.
Denver ephedra attorney. Liquid ephedra. Twinlab ripped fuel with ephedra. Ephedra liquid gel products. Yellow jackets with ephedra. Ephedra.
Fatal amount of xanax.
Buy xanax. Xanax no prescription. Order xanax. Xanax prescription. Overdose xanax. Xanax on line.
Ephedra pills.
Ephedra yellow swarm. Ephedra yellow bullets. Buy ephedra online drugstores yellow swarms. Diet pills with ephedra. Colorado ephedra lawyer. Hunt on for ephedra substitutes cbs news. Buy ephedra online.
Ephedrine.
Ephedrine. Health risks of ephedrine. Ephedrine faq.
Ephedrine.
Ephedrine. Dangers of ephedrine. Ephedrine weight loss products. Ephedrine hydrochloride. Baseball player dies from ephedrine.
Tylenol with codeine elixir dosing.
Tylenol with codeine 3. Codeine tylenol umaxppc.
Buy prozac phentermine online free shipping cheap.
Buy prozac phentermine online free shipping cheap.
Online consultation oxycodone.
Oxycodone online. Online consultation oxycodone. Online pharmacy oxycodone. Buy oxycodone online without.
Order tramadol.
Online order tramadol. Order tramadol. Order tramadol online consultation.
Levitra vardenafil.
Levitra vardenafil.
Doxycycline periostat .
Doxycycline periostat .
Do meridia phentermine wo.
Pillinc buy phentermine adipex meridia online. Online pharmacies phentermine xenical meridia.
Buy generic xanax online.
Xanax online. Buy generic xanax online. Buy xanax online. Xanax online rss feed.
Buy norco online.
Norco online. Buy norco online.
Buy amoxicillin without prescription.
Buy amoxicillin with no prescription. Buy amoxicillin online cheap amoxicillin. Buy amoxicillin without prescription.
Canine dosage of hydrocodone vicodin.
Vicodin hydrocodone. Hydrocodone vicodin. Hydrocodone bitartrate vs vicodin. Hydrocodone apap 7.5 750 tbmck vicodin.
Order norco no prescription.
Order norco.
Search fluoxetine hydrochloride prozac day fd.
Search fluoxetine hydrochloride prozac day fd.
Phentermine vs meridia.
Phentermine vs meridia. Pillinc buy phentermine adipex meridia online. Online adipex meridia phentermine prescription viagra. Online prescription viagra phentermine meridia adipex.
Oxycontin online no prescription.
Buy oxycontin online without a prescription. Oxycontin prescription online. Oxycontin online. Online no prescription oxycontin pharmacy. Buy oxycontin online. Cheap oxycontin online.
Buy codeine no prescription free delivery.
Buy soma codeine online. Buy codeine online without prescription. Buy codeine. Buy codeine online without a prescription. Buying codeine in canada.
Oxycontin mail order without prescription mexican.
Order prescription oxycontin. Mail order oxycontin.
Buy tramadol.
Buy tramadol online. Buy tramadol online cod. Buy tramadol. Buy tramadol cheap medication 35009 buy. Buy cheap tramadol.
Order hydrocodone with no medical recods.
Order hydrocodone cod. Order hydrocodone without a prescription. Hydrocodone order overnight shipping. Order hydrocodone online without prescription. Order hydrocodone online with phone consultation. Order hydrocodone online legally. Can you really order hydrocodone.
Doxycycline hyclate.
Doxycycline hyclate.
Fioricet online.
Buy fioricet online generic fioricet cheap. Buying fioricet online with no prescription. Buy fioricet with codeine online. Generic fioricet online. Order fioricet online.
Hydrocodone order.
Order hydrocodone online. Order hydrocodone without a prescription.