Last evening, Eduflack had the honor of testifying before the District of Columbia State Board of Education on DC’s student assessment scores and how they can be used in state-level policy development. For those unawares, DC is an interesting case study in education system structure. DC is both a State Education Agency (SEA) and a Local Education Agency (LEA). The DC State Board serves as a state board in Massachusetts, Texas, or California would, and the SEA is headed by former U.S. Department of Education official Dr. Kerri Briggs. The SEA is responsible not only for DC Public Schools, but also for the growing number of charter schools in our nation’s capital (with nearly a third of the District’s students attending charters, it is quite some job for the Office of the State Superintendent of Education (OSSE)).
I was the closing act for a three-part hearing. The panel first heard from Mike Casserly, the chief of the Council of Great City Schools, who spoke to what other urban school districts are doing with their assessments and their data. Then they heard a detailed presentation from State Superintendent Briggs and her staff, providing far greater detail on the DC-CAS numbers than was originally provided by the Mayor and Chancellor Rhee back in July. Yours truly followed up the rear.
For readers who recall, I was harsh on DCPS back in July when they released the initial numbers. I was concerned that student achievement, on the whole, ticked up, but there was a drop in AYP. I was worried by Rhee’s comments about picking the low-hanging fruit to achieve those gains, knowing such fruit is now gone for later year replication. And I was worried about declaring victory based on one or two years of data, when four or five years of real, substantive data is really necessary to see the true impact of reforms.
I was impressed with the probing questions the DCSBOE asked of OSSE and of the data, particularly its persistence in asking for greater disaggregation and a better understanding of what they do with what they have. So what, exactly, did little ole Eduflack recommend to the District’s education leaders? I can break it down into five key points.
1. The District should be reassured by the numbers presented by OSSE. After further reflection and additional breakdowns, we can see that specific schools in DC are indeed trending up (though there are still some worry spots). More importantly, DC is breaking the national cycle and is really making some progress in closing the achievement gap. Both black and Hispanic achievement numbers were on the rise, while white student achievement remained relatively flat (noting, though, that only 5 percent of DC schoolchildren are white).
2. The most important data sets for DCSBOE to be concerned with should not be DC-CAS, but rather NAEP and NAEP-TUDA. These data sets are the most accurate yardstick for determining how DC’s students are doing. The District needs to better use the NAEP data, better slicing and dicing it to really understand what the data means and how it can be applied. DC also needs to avoid falling victim to the typical NAEP horserace games. This is not about trying to catch Massachusetts in eighth grade reading NAEP or trying to outdo Atlanta in NAEP-TUDA. DC needs to look at the data, look at the gaps, and set clear goals based on where DC is, and where they want it to head.
3. As important as assessments are, Superintendent Briggs is correct. It makes little sense to rework DC’s tests before core standards are complete and we know what new skills and benchmarks we are supposed to be measuring. But rather than focusing on the assessment tool itself, DC needs to start taking a far closer look at its overall data system and how that system is better put to use. This shouldn’t be about collecting more data, it is about better using the existing data. How do they further disaggregate the numbers so DC families have a better sense for how individual schools and classrooms are doing? How do they look at the data longitudinally, so they are not just measuring this year’s fourth graders against next year’s fourth graders, but are seeing how this years fourth graders are doing, performance wise, in fifth, sixth, and even eighth grades.
DC not only needs to determine that it is improving, but it needs to know why. The system has been layering reform after reform in the schools over the past several years. It is near impossible to decide what is responsible for the gains and what is the chafe that should probably be cut away so the effective interventions can do their jobs. In monitoring the schools and classes that are showing the most progress, DC needs to track the efforts that are resulting in those gains, looking at the clusters of specific interventions, and try to diagnose the best and promising practices that are happening in DC classrooms.
4. With that information, DC needs to do a better job of applying what it learns. Principals and teachers need to be better trained in how to use the data, both before they enter the teaching profession and once they are there. Best practices needs to be shared and modeled across the district. Effective teachers need to serve as mentors for new teachers so they can teach good behaviors (hopefully before one has to unteach bad behaviors.) And we need to give time for new interventions and reforms to take place. While four or five years may seem like an eternity in education reform, changing horses after just a year or two of data, even if it is promising, is not necessarily in the best interests of DC’s students in the long run.
Many members of the board were focused on the back end, asking what could be done with regard to high school dropouts and college-going rates. I urged them to look at the front end as well, and make sure that OSSE’s focus on investment in high-quality early childhood education is successfully translated into real ECE opportunities in DCPS. One only needs to look at the impact of the Abbott decisions in New Jersey, and see how good early childhood education has now impacted student achievement and the achievement gap in some of the Garden State’s historically worst-performing school districts, to see that the gateway to long-term student achievement happens before kindergarten, and not in middle and high school.
5. Finally, this is a team game, and not a one-man sport. Chancellor Rhee cannot do this by herself, nor can the DCSBOE take the responsibility entirely on its shoulders. Lasting school improvement requires real buy in from parents and families, teachers, students, and the community at large. With families in particular, they don’t necessarily understand the arcane definitions of AYP (particularly now that the U.S. Department of Education doesn’t even want to use the term), nor should they have to. They want assurances that their kids are going to good schools, and if they aren’t good, they want assurances that everything is being done to improve them. At the end of the day, families want to believe their neighborhood schools are good, particularly because they usually have affection for the principal and the teachers. If all are invested in school turnaround, and all understand how we are doing it and how we are measuring it, we will come further faster.
Ultimately, it comes down to one key issue — how do we use the data we have? In most cities and most SEAs, we have a wealth of data points, probably far more than most know are even there. What we do with it is what is most important. How do we use it to shape both teaching and learning? How do teachers use data to implement specific in
terventions for struggling students? How do we ID promising practice so it can be shared? How do we find the most effective teachers and learn why they are effective? How do we support what is working, while cutting away what may be tried, but is having no real impact? How do we invest in the student, and not just the system?
A lot of questions, yes. But just the sort of thinking many state boards are pondering as they enter into this new world order of assessments, data systems, achievement, innovation, and the like.
514 thoughts on “Data Use in Our Nation’s Capital”
Cheap soma. Buy soma cheap. Soma buy soma cheap soma soma online. Watson soma cheap. Cheap watson soma online.
Cheap soma. Watson soma cheap.
Buy cheap phentermine.
Buy phentermine online. Buy phentermine no prescription. Mg buy phentermine. Buy phentermine.
Discount valium. Cheap valium free shipping. Valium on line. Valium no prescription needed. Valium. Order valium. Generic valium.
Cheap online purchase viagra.
Buy viagra online. Viagra online. Online viagra sample. Purchase viagra online. Cheap viagra lowest prices online.
Phentermine. Buy phentermine on line.
Buy cheap online pharmacy ultram.
Cheap ultram online today discount. Buy ultram online cod fast. Online pharmacy ultram. Buy ultram online.
Viagra buy viagra online.
Viagra online add to cart. Online viagra. Viagra prescription online.
Buy prescription soma without.
Buy soma cod.
Buy phentermine on line.
Mg buy phentermine. Buy phentermine cheap phentermine diet pills index.
Buy fioricet online that ships to missouri.
Buy fioricet bloghoster. Buy fioricet. Buy fioricet full information amp low prices. Buy fioricet online without a prescription.
Casino royale. Casino royale reviews. James bond casino royal. Casino royal james bond. Buffalo bills casino. Casino royale trailer.
Adderall like effect.
How do you dissolve adderall. Adderall without prescription. Adderall abuse. How while on adderall xr. Adderall.
Soma next day. Soma to florida. Soma. Addiction to soma. Soma and addiction.
Buy phentermine online.
Cheap phentermine. Buy phentermine. Discount phentermine. Phentermine. Phentermine dosage.
Azithromycin side effects. Order azithromycin. Azithromycin. Azithromycin skin rash.
Is codeine legal.
What is apap codeine. Codeine false positives.
Discount phentermine. Phentermine. Order phentermine online. Phentermine for sale.
Can you snort percocet. Percocet. Percocet dependency. Buy percocet online without office visit.
Fioricet and blood work.
Fioricet prescription. Generic fioricet low prices amp fast delivery. Fioricet. Fioricet online. Fioricet information from drugs com. Cheapest fioricet.
Tramadol saturday delivery.
Tramadol shipped to florida. Tramadol 180 cod. Tramadol hydrochloride. Tramadol hcl. Medlineplus drug information tramadol and. Tramadol.
Codeine and pseudoephedrine separation.
Tylenol with codeine elixir dosing. Codeine dextromethorphan. Codeine. Source of codeine. Guaifenesin codeine.
Xanax presciption. Xanax. Xanax without prescription. Xanax 2mg.
Oxycontin no prescription.
Oxycontin. Discontinued oxycontin. Generic oxycontin photo. No quarter is max boot using oxycontin. Buy cheap oxycontin. Where to buy oxycontin.
Amoxicillin. Expiration date for amoxicillin. How quickly does amoxicillin work. Amoxicillin order mexico mexican. Taking amoxicillin while pregnant.
Fioricet watson. Fioricet loratab.
Buy diazepam news. Duration of diazepam. Diazepam.
Viagra. Women and viagra. Over the counter viagra. Viagra samples. Viagra uk. Viagra clips. Re viagra cello.
Canada overnight ambien.
Ambien buy. Ambien overnight.
Ativan purchase. Ativan halucinate. Generic ativan. Ativan side effects.
Viagra for women.
Viagra. Order viagra online. Women and viagra. Order viagra. Viagra side effects.
Tramadol online. Buy tramadol. Tramadol. Tramadol for dogs.
Previcid verses protonix. Risks of protonix. Cost of protonix. Acute gastrointestinal bleeding protonix drip. Side effects protonix. Cheap protonix. Compare protonix to prilosec. Rash caused from protonix. Nexium protonix.
Atacand. Discontinuing of atacand.
Lamisil cream cure toenail fungus.
Soma snakeoil. Cheap watson soma online. Soma. Soma carisoprodol. Buy soma online. Soma drug. Cheap soma.
Arcoxia. Nissen and arcoxia and medal. Medal and arcoxia and database and clinical.
Butalbital cod payment.
Butalbital. Effects of butalbital. Ibuprofen and butalbital safe to mix. Butalbital wikipedia.
Enalapril dog. Enalapril. Enalapril maleate.
Ambien and side effects.
Ambien sleeping pill. Ambien. Cheaper ambien prescription. Generic ambien. Ambien and the menstrual cycle. Discount ambien. Ambien cr. Ambien and brain injuries.
Effects of vicodin.
Convert vicodin to oxycotin. Order vicodin. Vicodin es.
Side effects of prozac.
Viagra. Generic viagra.
Connecticut oxycontin attorneys.
What if i drink with seroquel. Seroquel side effects. Seroquel withdrawal symptoms. Seroquel.
Cialis vs viagra vs levitra.
Buy levitra. Buy levitra online.
Sexual dysfunction lamictal.
Nizoral candida. Nizoral side effects. Nizoral cost. Nizoral mg. Nizoral.
Buy xanax. Buy 180 xanax 2mg. Beer and xanax. Xanax. Xanax xr.
Avian flu and tamiflu. Tamiflu recall. Tamiflu parvo. Tamiflu. Dosage tamiflu.