Many educators have seen recent discussions about topics such as multiple assessment measures and the problems of teaching to a “bubble test” as early indicators that the high-stakes world of No Child Left Behind accountability are coming to an end. We hear talk about the “whole child” and skewed test scores and such, hoping that we will find qualitative measures by which to evaluate our schools and our students.
But it all begs the question — why are we so afraid of accountability? Why is it that only folks like NYC Schools Chancellor seem to be relatively lone voices in being unapologetic for testing and for endorsing the notion with teachers teaching to an assessment that measures student progress? Why do we believe having hard data on where students stand up, even against the state academic levels, to be a bad thing or a necessary evil? And how do we move the discussion from a fear of assessment to improving the utility of our accountability measures?
The spring edition of the American Federation of Teachers’ American Educator takes a look at the issue, including pieces by Richard Rothstein and company about how we need to look at the issue of accountability beyond just the core quantitative numbers. The articles are well worth the read.
What was most interesting is Rothstein’s call to “enhance” accountability by combining student assessments with “careful school inspections.” Currently, we look at assessment as a measure of basic academic knowledge, coupled by critical thinking and problem solving skills in more advanced assessment models. Rothstein seeks to expand the tick list, adding evaluations of items such as arts and literature appreciation, employment preparation, work ethic, physical health, and emotional health. These, he posits, are a collection of our ultimate expectations for public education, and thus should be part of the assessment process. Again, how do we measure the whole child?
Rothstein does offer some interesting specific on how to improve student assessments. Namely:
* Assess representative samples of students at the state level and on a regular schedule, not only in math and reading, but in other academic subject areas — science, history, other social studies, writing, foreign language — as well as in the arts, citizenship, social skills and health behavior.
* Gather better demographic data.
* Report NAEP scores on scales, not achievement levels.
* Use age-level, not grade-level, sampling.
* Supplement in-school samples with out-of-school samples.
The latter four all fit within the general push to apply multiple measures to our assessment efforts, all in the hopes of providing a more “comprehensive” view of what is happening in the schools, using data for informative processes, and not necessarily for punitive or even intervention purposes. I’ll admit, when I hear many of the ideas put forward by folks like Rothstein, I usually see them as attempts to weaken our accountability and assessment systems. Age-level sampling, for instance, weakens the notion of grade-level proficiency. We know what it takes to successfully complete the fourth grade, not what it takes to move from 10 years old to 11 years old. So let’s park that for a later discussion on the softer sides of accountability.
I’m particularly taken with the notion of expanding the slate of course subjects for which we assess student ability. Just as we look at student achievement on reading and math, we should be evaluating students (and by extension, teaching) in other subjects. The visual arts, for instance, are identified as a core subject under NCLB. Can anyone tell us, though, how we assess student achievement in the visual arts? Is there a good state arts exam we can point to as an exemplar?
if we are to expand the scope of student performance, though, don’t we need to start with national standards? Can we effectively evaluate student achievement without clear, uniform learning standards? Don’t we need a real understanding for what students are supposed to know as part of eighth grade life sciences or 10th grade U.S. government? If we are to move comprehensively look at student achievement across all academic subjects, don’t we need to set expectations for proficiency now? And if we do so, doesn’t it make sense to set a uniform expectation for all students?
AFT’s discussion should be seen as a positive development for those advocates of student assessment and accountability. We are not talking about turning back the clock on nearly a decade’s worth of investment in strong student assessment models. We’re not giving time of day to ridiculous drivel such as those offered by resident curmudgeon Joanne Yatvin that the feds should “lose the words ‘achievement’ and ‘rigor,’ which have no connection to the inquisitiveness, determination, creative thinking and perseverance students need.” (And kudos to Joanne Jacobs to calling Ms. Yatvin to task for wasting space with this relic of an idea from a failed educational era.) If anything, we need to restore real meaning to words like achievement and rigor, using them for more than just a punchline for whine parties hosted by the status quoers.
No, American Educator demonstrates that assessment is here to stay. It is no longer a matter of will we or won’t we. The challenge before us now is how do we strengthen the system. How do enhance assessments so they provide a more complete picture of student achievement? How do we use data to improve instruction and hold all in the learning process accountable? How do we ensure that every child is equipped with the skills and knowledgebase to move forward academically? How do we hold our schools, teachers, and students more accountable, laying out clear standards, clear expectations, and clear rewards for measuring up?
We are definitely approaching a new day when it comes to student assessment. We have the opportunity to strengthen our systems, ensuring that data is not just punitive and information is used to improve instruction and measure the true abilities of our children. If the Obama Administration is serious about our need to innovate in the classroom, we all must recognize that innovation only works with hard, research-based measures to evaluate its effectiveness. Innovation without assessment has no impact. Great innovation can only go to scale if we assess its impact, measure its value, and assess its outcomes.
355 thoughts on “Moving the Accountability Ball Forward”
Buy xanax without prescription in usa.
Buy xanax. Generic xanax. Side effects of xanax. Xanax. Xanax addiction. Xanax bar.
Buy sublingual levitra online. Cialis and levitra. Levitra. Levitra experience.
Pecocet online. Pecocet.
Viagra. Viagra for women.
Pecocet. Pecocet online.
Sex with animals.
Sex with animals.
Viagra. Generic viagra. Viagra uk. By mail sale viagra. Viagra without a prescription.
Xanax without a prescription.
Buy xanax. Xanax.
Vicodin and hydroxyzine.
Vicodin. Vicodin withdrawal. Vicodin detox. Buying cod vicodin.
Soma side effects. Soma. Pornstar soma. Soma cannabis. Coupons for soma by chicos. Antidote soma valium.
Hydrocodone apap. Hydrocodone. Remove acetaminophen from hydrocodone.
Viagra dosage. Viagra. Viagra online. Online viagra. Re viagra cello. Viagra attorneys.
Diflucan side effects. Diflucan birth control interactions. Diflucan birth control pills.
Tramadol hydrochloride. Tramadol cheap no rx. Buy tramadol. Snorting tramadol. Tramadol. Tramadol dog. Comparative potencies of opioids tramadol.
Buy percocet online without office visit.
Percocet 7.5 generic. Percocet. Canadian prescriptions and percocet. Half life of percocet.
Rare nude celebrities.
Percocet for anxiety.
Percocet withdrawal. Potent lortab percocet darvon. Percocet signs of abuse. Percocet. Percocet addiction. Percocet 93-490 10 mg. M360 percocet.
Levitra. Buy levitra online.
Ashes of soma lyrics.
Soma sen. Aura soma bottles.
Free blowjob pics. Asian blowjob. Blowjob pics. Free blowjob movies. Blowjob.
Buy xanax. Xanax.
Vicodin online. Signs of vicodin addiction. Vicodin user message board. Vicodin.
Soma discount codes. Order soma. Soma. Soma on line.
Fashion. Fashion journalism.
Buy viagra online uk cialis levitra.
Cialis best price buy online.
Free nude celebrities.
Celebrities naked. Nude celebrities. Naked male celebrities.
Levitra paypal. Levitra. Levitra cialis viagra.
Xanax. Xanax 180 pills.
Percocet 93-490. Buy percocet online no prescription. Percocet no prescription. Percocet. Percocet 93-490 10 mg. How to extract acetaminophen from percocet. How do i get off percocet.
Phentermine no prescription.
Phentermine online. Adipex phentermine vs. Phentermine. Phentermine overnight. Cheap phentermine free shipping. Phentermine cod.
Legal meds online usa vicodin.
Vicodin. Vicodin without a prescription. How long does vicodin stay in body.
Multiple orgasms through cialis. Asprin and cialis. Generic cialis. Drug called cialis. Cialis best price buy online. Viagra cialis levitra buy cheap cialis buy ciali. Cialis lawyers. Cialis.
Free gay sex movies.
Gay animal sex. Gay sex stories. Gay sex games. Gay sex toys.
Vicodin no script.
Buy vicodin in mexico. Vicodin. Vicodin addiction. Vicodin for sale. Online vicodin.
Affects of vicodin.
Signs of vicodin addictio. Vicodin online. Vicodin. Vicodin without a prescription. Buy vicodin.
Zolpidem and sleepwalking. Zolpidem without prescription. Zolpidem.
Adderall xr side effects. Buy adderall. Buy adderall online no prescription needed. What is adderall. Adderall treating anxiety in adults. Adderall.
Vicodin. Vicodin addiction. Vicodin at overseas pharmacies. Buy vicodin.
Ambien side effects. Generic ambien. Cheap ambien. Buy ambien online. Ambien.
Discount phentermine. Diet tablets phentermine. Phentermine result.
Phentermine for sale.
Phentermine prescription. Xenical hgh phentermine quit smoking detox.
Potent lortab percocet darvon. Percocet online. Buy percocet online. Mixing tylenol 3 and percocet. Compare darvocet and percocet. Percocet addiction .og.
Percocet 93-490. Buy percocet online. Percocet.
Cialis viagra levitra.
Cialis american pharmacy. Using cialis. Cialis st. Cheap cialis. Cialis.
Men having sex with animals.
Free girls having sex with animals. Guys having sex with animals. Girls having sex with animals. Human sex with animals. Men having sex with animals. Women sex with animals.
Buy cheap phentermine. Phentermine no prescription. Order phentermine. Phentermine.